卡拉楊 - 貝多芬交響曲

goodies

小弟一直以為卡拉楊-柏林交響樂團 -貝多芬交響曲全套錄音只有DGG那三套,
但最近發現竟然有第四套,  原來卡拉楊帶領柏交七十年代係日本巡迴演奏時竟然奏足全套貝交, (你話日本七十年代幾有錢)
這套是當時的現場錄音, 由Tokyo FM以sacd 發行, 一共五隻碟獨立發售(每隻1,800yen), 除此之外還有貝鋼協3同5,
其實卡拉揚一直不是我那杯茶, 但暫時聽咗3, 5, 6, 7同鋼協3,5之後竟然令我有點驚喜, (唔知係唔係冇得俾卡拉揚自己亂搞d錄音嘅原因)
音效方面, 日本的錄音絶對不用懷疑, 如果喜歡貝交, 或卡拉揚的話這套就實在不容錯過,
香港各大唱片公司都冇得賣(想係香港欣賞古典音樂真係....), 尖東有間SACD專門店可能有售,
不過我自己那套就直接去日本網站訂返嚟

vincecharus

My favorite Beethoven interpreter is Wilhelm Furtwangler.  Karajan is good, but Furtwangler is perhaps the greatest genius ever. His interpretation of Beethoven (and other music) is incomparably moving!

Antfi

Love both Karajan and Furtwangler but recently I listen to Carlos Kleiber's Beethoven more...

vincecharus

Carlos Kleiber has only recorded Beethoven ##4, 5, & 7 as far as I know. He is a genius giving perfect interpretations, of course.

goodies

vincecharus 發表於 2013-8-10 20:03
My favorite Beethoven interpreter is Wilhelm Furtwangler.  Karajan is good, but Furtwangler is perha ...

Yes, I agreed.  Furtwangler's Beethoven is my all time favorite, I don't think any one can come close to his interpretation of Beethoven or Wagner.

Since Beethoven's symphony is my favorite piece of classical music, I try to collect and listen to all different recording by different conductors and orchestras.  Some time I can as crazy as listen to 5 to 6 different recordings of the same symphony in one day.  Furtwangler is the first one that after I listen to one piece of his Beethoven, I have the desire to listen the complete cycle.  The second one is Celibidache.

As I said in my thread, Karajan is really not my cup of tea.  Actually, I dislike most of his work, but after I listen to above recording, this is the third time I have the same desire.

I don't know how to say why, only as I know is music speak for itself.

vincecharus

Do you know that Hong Kong conductor Carmen Koon has studied under Celidibache?

花輪

有無C兄鐘意Harnoncourt -COE版本呀？
有別各德奧大師∼

goodies

vincecharus 發表於 2013-8-10 20:40
Do you know that Hong Kong conductor Carmen Koon has studied under Celidibache?

The following quote from CUHK music dept. web page.

"She obtained a scholarship to study conducting with Professor C. A. Bunte (Celibidache's student) at Hochschule der Kunste Berlin."

vincecharus

花輪 發表於 2013-8-10 20:44
有無C兄鐘意Harnoncourt -COE版本呀？
有別各德奧大師∼

Period or modern instruments?

vincecharus

goodies 發表於 2013-8-10 20:47
The following quote from CUHK music dept. web's page.

"She obtained a scholarship to study cond ...

She actually studied under Celibidache as well.

goodies

vincecharus 發表於 2013-8-10 20:48
She actually studied under Celibidache as well.

Oh, really!

vincecharus

Good to see classical music discussion threads here!

花輪

vincecharus 發表於 2013-8-10 20:47
Period or modern instruments?

現代樂器版，但係用返接近原譜沖度，
舊樂器當然首推Hogwood，Gardiner版個人不喜歡

vincecharus

花輪 發表於 2013-8-10 20:57
現代樂器版，但係用返接近原譜沖度，
舊樂器當然首推Hogwood，Gardiner版個人不喜歡

Interesting! May look into it...

goodies

花輪 發表於 2013-8-10 20:44
有無C兄鐘意Harnoncourt -COE版本呀？
有別各德奧大師∼

咦, 走漏了,
師兄, 香港有售嗎?

花輪

vincecharus 發表於 2013-8-10 21:01
Interesting! May look into it...

Gardiner版就真係原譜沖度，
不過真係太快了，個人覺得...

vincecharus

goodies 發表於 2013-8-10 21:02
咦, 走漏了,
師兄, 香港有售嗎?

Does anyone still buy classical CD in HK anymore?

goodies

原來咁多高手係度, 真係班門弄斧

goodies

vincecharus 發表於 2013-8-10 21:03
Does anyone still buy classical CD in HK anymore?

有時, 但多數不是.

依家好似浄番歐洲同日本有出古典CD, 美國好似死哂

vincecharus

goodies 發表於 2013-8-10 21:05
原來咁多高手係度, 真係班門弄斧

師兄，good to share our musical interests with friends here!