最强對最強……50AA vs 50ELCAN (已上新圖)

alphard

C9.99 發表於 2014-4-1 14:27
唏噓的鬚根

Leica Summicron 50mm f/2 APO ASPH

aa 實净D (可能我硬頸)

vincecharus

Ming, were your self-portraits @ f/2?

This time both photos appear to be in focus.

AA has incredible resolution as advertised.

Elcan looks flatter but some c-hings may find its lower contrast more appealing.

Both are winners.

The only loser is M240.  Auto white balance sucks, especially for AA.

C9.99

vincecharus 發表於 2014-4-1 14:58
Ming, were your self-portraits @ f/2?

This time both photos appear to be in focus.

Yes. they are all by f/2, in this set, AA wins in sharpness.

M3fans

AA wins in certain areas as expected, but too little, again

bubu

张三丰徒手对决変形金刚...

就算拉匀差唔多、平手，Elcan都已經赢左。

Sawlo2000

elcan seems to have a tint of soft glow, or is it me?

chijeffrey

Elcan's bokeh sure out win the modern AA

grandetech

AA終於贏左條毛，不過超過兩皮都唔會買

achiever237

In my limited experience, without scientific proof, I find Elcan glass seems somehow better in lighting control.
It also seems they are very good in control "light fare" or common difficult lighting conditions.

Elcan also always produce " true" colour.  In simple words, what colour you see is what colour you get. Not much cosmetic or character like others.

It could be the military DNA it owns.

Just my 2 cents

Thomas_Chan

bebe456 發表於 2014-3-31 14:48
花生 ~~~ 兩斤花生 !

一（呈瓦）白干！

kgv

剛剛 “尋回” 支 Elcan Canada 2"

隨手打翻張

原圖 個 resolution 又真喺 無得輸 wor ...

samwu

kgv

kgv 發表於 2014-4-8 18:43
剛剛 “尋回” 支 Elcan Canada 2"

隨手打翻張

“尋回” ...
喺 唔知 塞咗去 邊個 dry box 入面
剛剛 找位 擺 銀11663 才見翻佢 ...

charliebrown88

kgv 發表於 2014-4-8 18:50
“尋回” ...
喺 唔知 塞咗去 邊個 dry box 入面
剛剛 找位 擺 銀11663 才見翻佢 ... ...

哈哈，k San 你要點倉加個inventory list 貼在dry box 面，小弟願意做小幫工

kgv

Lips, "唔知點解套機一出我就覺得你會買"

我已經掙扎過 ga laaa
推咗 Ming 哥 一次 great offer
點知
肥 Apple 兄 又使出一招 靚 number ...
咁 就淪撼咗

M3fans

ming 哥 test results confirmed by ksan, elcan has great image quality

Sawlo2000

宜家咁唔駛買Lu.  大家都「候」住。。。

kgv

吶，找到兩張舊相 (taken while I still had the 50AA)
三張一齊比較吓
(記得 click 大張圖來睇吖)

kgv

V 兄
when I played around with the newly bought AA, I didn't know whereabout the Elcan was
but then one of my good friends here said he wanted to have an AA asap, so I let it go.
I only "re-discovered" this Elcan yesterday

charliebrown88

kgv 發表於 2014-4-9 17:05
吶，找到兩張舊相 (taken while I still had the 50AA)
三張一齊比較吓
(記得 click 大張圖來睇吖)

第一同第二張wb 差咁遠